I have ordered from these guys at least 4 or 5 times. I love these Chicago style deep dish pizzas! I guarantee you these are better than any of the more well-known places because I have tried all of them too. Also, these guys always pack these extremely well, shipping is very reasonable, and they always include a personalized note with their signatures on it thanking me for my purchase. It's a very thoughtful and personal touch. I don't know why all of the restaurants on here don't do that. If you are a fan of meatballs, order those too. Anyway, I can't recommend this place more.
These pizzas are huge and delicious! I noticed one comment saying not enough sauce, visually I might agree, but it packs a nice saucy kick. Love these!
This is the Best Pizza 🍕 I have ever had outstanding. I am reordering this weekend. Top of the line. Thanks, Mark
I enjoyed having pizza to share for New Years Eve. The pizza was delicious!!! I miss how good pizza from the Midwest tastes now that I live in Colorado. Thank You! Angie
Short Hills, NJ
This is the real thing! After many attempts to enjoy the Chicago pizza of our dreams outside Chicago—thick, crunchy outside crust with slightly salty finish, generous tub of creamy but not overly stringy cheese, tangy and assertive but not overwhelming sauce—Bartolini's did it for us. Sound like I'm describing a fine wine?I 'm not embarrassed because we've been seeking this pizza nostalgia trip for decades and have finally found it. The pies survive freezing well and also reheat acceptably. Thank you, Bartolini Bros --we'll be back.
Not only did the pizza get here on time and in perfect condition it was a bargain and fed 12 people easily!!!!! Good job Bartolinis!!!!!!!
Not nearly enough sauce for how big pizza is.
We have made multiple orders for these pizzas; the quality is superior.
We've had the cheese and it's fabulous! Love it!
One star goes to FoodyDirect for their delivery service; the pizzas arrived on time as promised. However, the remaining stars are for the Bartolini’s deep-dish pizzas; they were tasty. The overall build of each pizza was nice; they were oozing with cheese, their crusts were flavorfully thick/soft/crunchy, and the tomato sauce was just right (it didn’t taste acidic or too sweet). Only wished that the pizza with the spinach had more spinach; it was really lacking in that topping (especially for it to be a spinach pizza). But, the meatball and the sausage pizzas were really good.
Flat Rock, NC
Have been looking for an excellent deep dish since I left Chicago, and this was it! Ordered three different deep dish as well as two thin crust and all where a big hit. Ordered for my wife's family in Water Mill NY and everyone loved them. I live in Flat Rock, NC and will reorder for my self as soon as we return!
Perfection! Excellently and carefully packed. Flavor was spot on! Would highly recommend!
Loved them. Can't get this kind of pizza in Memphis. Great delivery, pizza ice cold when they arrived!! Beautiful pizzas--delicious
Excellent pizzas! I will most likely be ordering from this place again.
Pizzas can be stored in your refrigerator for 2-3 days after arrival, or can be frozen for up to 2 months. If frozen, be sure to move pizza to the refrigerator the day before baking, so it can defrost fully overnight.
Thaw your pizza overnight in the refrigerator.
Preheat oven to 400°F. Remove all packaging and place the pizza on a cookie sheet or Pizza Stone. Bake fully thawed pizza about 35-45 minutes, or until the crust is a nice golden brown and pizza is hot throughout.