Cheesecake Sampler
Choose your Delivery Date at Check Out!

As Inc. Magazine put it in their 14 Foodie Gifts holiday roundup (December 2016), "If you can't find a cheesecake variety you like in this sampler, you might not like cheese cake."


This spectacular sampler supplies you with 12 slices in various flavors. You'll get their seven most popular flavors—plain, strawberry, blueberry, cherry, pineapple, caramel pecan, and rocky road—along with five “surprise” slices that pay tribute to whatever spectacular flavors Eileen’s is baking up at the moment.


Flavors include:

  • Blueberry
  • Cherry
  • Plain
  • Marble
  • Carmel Pecan
  • Banana

Ships Monday through Friday via overnight service
Order by Thursday at 3:00PM (ET) for delivery by Friday

Scroll To Top
Shipping Days
MON TUE WED THU FRI
Icon check Icon check Icon check Icon check Icon check
Low Flat-Rate Shipping for Eileen's Cheesecake

$ 34.95 Flat-Rate Shipping - Due to the higher temperatures during the summer months all cheesecakes from Eileen's Special Cheesecake will be shipped via Next Day Air for delivery by Noon. You will be presented with a flat rate of $34.95 for UPS Next Day Air upon checkout.


*Please note that the flat rates above will be applied per shipping box. While some packages can be combined into a single box, most packages from Arthur Avenue require their own shipping box. You will be presented with the actual shipping rate before finalizing your purchase.

Maptemplatefinal all eil summer

Saturday delivery is available for an additional charge.
Service to Alaska is for +$20 (sorry). Service to Hawaii and outside the U.S. currently not available.


Orders are shipped on Monday through Friday, except holidays. Orders placed by 3:00 PM (ET) can be shipped that day. Perishable items cannot be shipped over a weekend and cannot be delivered on Sunday or Monday.


Weather and unforeseen circumstances can delay your shipment. We strongly recommend that you schedule your order to arrive at least 1 business day before your desired usage date to allow for any delays.


Shipping Options

The following shipping options are available depending upon the delivery date selected:


UPS Next Day - Due to the higher temperatures during the summer months all perishable items from Arthur Avenue will be shipped via Next Day Air for delivery by Noon. You will be presented with a flat rate of $39.95 for UPS Next Day Air upon checkout.


Saturday Delivery - Saturday delivery is available for Next Day Air only, for an additional charge of $20 per shipment (for a total cost of $54.95). Deliveries are made between 10:30 AM and 12:00 PM (noon), depending upon delivery address. Saturday delivery is not available for UPS Ground shipments.


For complete shipping details we encourage you to visit our General Shipping and Packaging Information page.

Packaging & Delivery

All cheesecakes from Eileen's Special Cheesecake are shipped in extra thick recyclable foam containers with sufficient coolant to assure it arrives in excellent condition within the max allowable transit time of 1 day.

All orders are shipped signature release. This means UPS will leave the package at the doorstep, front desk or gate associated with the shipping address without requiring a signature upon delivery. It is the customer's responsibility to ensure that the contents of the package are stored in a freezer or refrigerator promptly after delivery. FoodyDirect cannot be responsible for orders with incomplete or invalid addresses, or that are sent to recipients who are not available to store the contents of the order on the day of arrival. UPS cannot deliver to a P.O. box.

Storage & Care

Refrigeration Instructions: Please unwrap all plastic and foam upon receipt and store in a refrigerator. Refrigerated cakes can be enjoyed for 7-10 days.


Freezing Instructions: After removing the gel ice pack from the box, do not unwrap the cake from its packaging if you choose to freeze it upon receipt- simply put the cake directly into your freezer. After enjoying, if you would like to re-freeze any leftovers, wrap the remaining cake in plastic. Cakes can be frozen for up to 3 months. The gel ice pack provided is reusable.


Slicing Instructions: Using a hot, wet knife- slice the cake and pull the knife from the bottom of the cake, do not lift. Clean the knife of any residue, making sure to repeat this step between every slice. OR Using unflavored dental floss, pull a piece longer than the cake and wrap around your fingertips. Pull it straight down on both sides of the cheese cake and gently pull out from the bottom, unwrapping one end from your fingertips. Run the floss between your fingertips to remove any crumb pieces and repeat.

Order Cut-Off Time:

All orders ship Mon thru Fri via overnight service. The cutoff time for same-day shipment of orders is 5:00 PM (ET).

Storage & Care:

Refrigeration Instructions: Please unwrap all plastic and foam upon receipt and store in a refrigerator. Refrigerated cakes can be enjoyed for 7-10 days.


Freezing Instructions: After removing the gel ice pack from the box, do not unwrap the cake from its packaging if you choose to freeze it upon receipt- simply put the cake directly into your freezer. After enjoying, if you would like to re-freeze any leftovers, wrap the remaining cake in plastic. Cakes can be frozen for up to 3 months. The gel ice pack provided is reusable.


Slicing Instructions:

Using a hot, wet knife- slice the cake and pull the knife from the bottom of the cake, do not lift. Clean the knife of any residue, making sure to repeat this step between every slice. OR Using unflavored dental floss, pull a piece longer than the cake and wrap around your fingertips. Pull it straight down on both sides of the cheese cake and gently pull out from the bottom, unwrapping one end from your fingertips. Run the floss between your fingertips to remove any crumb pieces and repeat.

Dietary Restrictions:

All Cheesecakes from Eileen's are Tablet-K Certified Kosher Click here to view their certification.

7 reviews
5
6
4
1
3
2
1

Richard
Irmo, SC
Posted on 01/06/2017

The Cheesecake was a gift sent to a friend's family. They said it was AMAZING! It was delivered timely and they all fought over each piece down to the last crumbs. On a scale of 1-10, they rated it an 11!. Thank you for making me the best gift giver ever.

John
Elmont, NY
Posted on 12/30/2016

great, grand daughter was very pleased with all the different taste.

Deb
Watertown, NY
Posted on 12/01/2016

Very yummy! Everyone loved it.

Bernita
Shawnee, KS
Posted on 08/17/2016

ordered it for mothers day. My mom said it tasted great

Vincenzo
Fort Benning, GA
Posted on 08/03/2016

My guests loved the cheesecake. As a Diabetic I did not taste it.

Claudette
Spartanburg, SC
Posted on 06/30/2016

best cheesecake ever,enjoyed all the different choices, delivery was great

Cynthia
Ridgefield, CT
Posted on 06/20/2016

Cheesecake was very good. It was light in consistency. Slices were a little difficult to separate from each other, but overall the sample was tasty. I would recommend adding the flavors to the inside of the box so you know what you are eating and can order a larger size of a particular flavor if you like one in particular.