Eileen's Classic NY Cheesecake

Choose your Delivery Date at Check Out!

Eileen's classic cheesecake is the cheesecake that started it all and turned Eileen into one of New York City’s most beloved bakers. Made from her mother’s recipe, which leverages a combination of cream cheese and sour cream (not ricotta, which is commonly used in Italian-style cheesecakes), and repeatedly touted as one of the city’s best authentic New York cheesecakes, it’s baked to order and shipped overnight to ensure you enjoy every last light, fluffy, and rich bite.

Ships FREE Monday through Friday via overnight service
Order by Thursday at 3:00PM (ET) for delivery by Friday

Scroll To Top

3 reviews

Santa Teresa, NM
Posted on 03/04/2017

It arrived so quick! Everything was fresh and delicious

Encinitas, CA
Posted on 01/02/2017

Fantastic, next time I'll order two !

Posted on 06/15/2016

Probably one of the two best cheesecakes I've ever experienced from New York. Would order again.

Shipping Days
Order Cut-Off Time:

All orders ship Mon thru Fri via overnight service. The cutoff time for same-day shipment of orders is 5:00 PM (ET).

Storage & Care:

Refrigeration Instructions: Please unwrap all plastic and foam upon receipt and store in a refrigerator. Refrigerated cakes can be enjoyed for 7-10 days. <br> Freezing Instructions: After removing the gel ice pack from the box, do not unwrap the cake from its packaging if you choose to freeze it upon receipt- simply put the cake directly into your freezer. After enjoying, if you would like to re-freeze any leftovers, wrap the remaining cake in plastic. Cakes can be frozen for up to 3 months. The gel ice pack provided is reusable. <br>

Slicing Suggestions:

Using a hot, wet knife- slice the cake and pull the knife from the bottom of the cake, do not lift. Clean the knife of any residue, making sure to repeat this step between every slice. OR Using unflavored dental floss, pull a piece longer than the cake and wrap around your fingertips. Pull it straight down on both sides of the cheese cake and gently pull out from the bottom, unwrapping one end from your fingertips. Run the floss between your fingertips to remove any crumb pieces and repeat.

Dietary Restrictions:

All Cheesecakes from Eileen's are Tablet-K Certified Kosher Click here to view their certification.