West Hempstead, NY
My FedEx delivery started with the box being left on its side on my porch. When I got to the box, it was partially crushed also. When opened, the pie had started to creep out of its pan and was very warm. That shouldn't have affected the taste. However, the crumb topping had sunk into the filling and became soft and doughy tasting. Cutting into the pie revealed that the crust was the same texture. Instead of being crisp and flaky, it was also soft and doughy. After cutting a slice, and tasting it, I was terribly disappointed. It tasted like a mushy version of a $5.00 Shoprite pie, certainly not the "religious experience" that Mario Batali described. Not only would I not purchase this pie again, but I hesitate to buy anything else without a reassurance that I wouldn't waste my money on similar baked goods.
Yum. This cherry pie was the perfect balance of sweet and tart. The crust and top were delicious. I normally would not order a cherry pie, but I would order this one again.
We have ordered this pie before and will again. You could eat this without the luscious cherries, it’s that good.
The pie was wonderful. It arrived ready to be served. We held it for three days in the fridge and it was excellent when we served it. Hope the next 11 pies are just as delicious.
West Palm Beach, FL
Delicious pie! It shipped in perfect condition and was fantastic. The crust was rich and flaky and the filling was filled with cherries. Will order again.
I am a baker from a family of bakers. I sent this pie to my family when circumstances would not permit making our own. I must say, the lie was impressive, the filling was cherries without all that syrupy goop typically found in "store bought" pies. The flavors of the fruit was bright and fresh and the crust was very good. I would purchase this pie again.
The Grand Traverse cherry pie was one of the best cherry pies I have had since my moms cherry pies when I was a child. These pies arent the sugar filled syrupy pies you get almost anywhere else. The pie and shipping are a pretty hefty price but if for the true cherry pie lover this is a difficult pie to pass over even if just for an occassional splurge. Love it, wish it was a bit cheaper and faster order to door.
OVERLAND PARK, KS
The crumb topping made a big difference to the taste of the filling. I thought that the cherries were a little small and The cherries themselves were tart. But if when I order again I will know what I am getting.
Forest Hills, NY
Can't stop ordering this pie! The best ever! I recommend it to anyone who loves pie, especially cherry!
This is THE BEST cherry pie we have EVER tasted! I think there is a little white frosting right under the top crust. To DIE FOR! Great for special occasions!
excellent. Just like homemade. Arrived in perfect condition.
It just doesn't get any better, nuff said! When I baked it and mind you I'm at a higher altitude in Colorado. But, the crust seem to crstyalize and the pie texture just magnified 60% even when the pie was cold. The cherries didn't mush up and it just came together. If you like cherries and haven't tried a cherry one. Then, you have missed a little piece of life.
The pie was absolutely delicious. The filling was tart and the pastry was tender and flaky. The only problem I had was that the filling overflowed in shipment and wet the packaging down to the box itself. It was a sticky mess. Would try it again, though.
Forest Hills, NY
This was the best cherry pie I've ever had! I love cherry pie so I've had a lot of them and this is by far the best. The crumb topping is sweet and yummy and goes well with the tartness of the cherries. If you love cherry pie this one will not disappoint you. I'm about to order two more! Apparently I don't want to be without it.
Very good. A little sweeter than I expected but still delicious.
it was not the very best cherry pie I ever had but it was very good.
Flower Mound, TX
Spectacular pie. The crust is light and flaky, and combine that with the tart cherries and it is like a slice of heaven. Well worth the cost, I always order a second pie in same order.
Fair nothing special...I was expecting better for the hype and $$$$$$. to much sugar on the crumb top and not enough cheeies.
This pie and their apple pie are our favorite. The filling and topping are scrumptious and that crust is even better. We order them three or four times a year.
|Shipping Days||Shipping Days|
All orders ship Mon thru Fri via FedEx 2 Day or faster. All pies and cakes are baked from scratch and require a two day lead time.
Fresh pies from Grand Traverse Pie Company should be enjoyed within 3 days of receipt, or can be stored frozen for up to 2 months.
Heat oven to 225 degrees. Warm for 20-30 minutes