Old Mission Cherry Pie

Choose your Delivery Date at Check Out!

The finest cherry pie you’ll ever taste! This traditional pie is packed with tart Montmorency cherries from Michigan and topped with an impeccably flaky pastry crust. It’s no wonder this amazing pie was featured in O, The Oprah Magazine.

Ships Monday through Friday via 2-Day or faster
Order by Monday at 4 PM (ET) for delivery by Friday

Pies come neatly packed in a Grand Traverse pie box.

Scroll To Top

3 reviews

Julie a.
Huntington, WV
Posted on 05/28/2017

I had this cherry pie delivered twice for gifts and both times the recipients raved about how delicious the pie was! Also with one of the deliveries I initially ordered pie from another company and it ended up being delivered all mushy and warm. I have to say "J" in customer service was great and let me order this cherry pie instead and all worked out. Would definitely order this cherry pie again!

Saint Augustine Beach, FL
Posted on 04/21/2017

Every pie day is an event for my mother in law especially her hubby passed. Our sister and brother in law are staying with her now. They say the anticipation is as good as pie day. I want to extend. I will get with the company. Thank you

Posted on 02/03/2017

This pie was sent as a gift for my husband, he ate every morsel with gusto! You are a hit!

Shipping Days
Order Cut-Off Time:

All orders ship Mon thru Fri via FedEx 2 Day or faster. All pies and cakes are baked from scratch and require a two day lead time.

Storage & Care:

Fresh pies from Grand Traverse Pie Company should be enjoyed within 3 days of receipt, or can be stored frozen for up to 2 months.