Key Lime Pie

Choose your Delivery Date at Check Out!

A food critics’ favorite, Little Pie Company’s sweet-tart key lime pie is made from real key lime juice. Smooth and creamy with a rich graham-cracker crust, it’s the ultimate taste of the tropics.

Orders ship Monday through Thursday via 2-Day or Faster
Ruffino Prosecco Pie ships via overnight only

Scroll To Top

31 reviews

Manchester, CT
Posted on 05/10/2018

Loved the Key Lime Pie leaves a tingly tang on your tongue. Still can't get over how good the Cherry Pie was I previously ordered will have to order again!!

Rev olivia
Crisfield, MD
Posted on 05/02/2018

excellent key lime pie. Have had others from this company -- soooo good!

Posted on 03/20/2018

I have ordered this key lime pie twice now and it is delicious. The crust is perfect with the filling. This is one of my favorite pies. I highly recommend trying the key lime pie.

Posted on 02/27/2018

Loved my Key Lime Pie! Super fresh and delivered right away. Just in time for Easter! Will order again and again and again!

Posted on 02/19/2018

This is the greatest! We ordered it on a cold gray day and when we took our first bite we felt like we were in the Caribbean!

West Lafayette, IN
Posted on 02/18/2018

Wonderful! Pie arrived intact, not overturned, as one had previously. If you've never tried it, you don't know what you're missing!

Posted on 02/16/2018

I just love Key Lime pie, and I have to say this one is the best! Not too sour and not too sweet.

Posted on 02/16/2018

I ordered this pie for St Patrick’s Day in 2017 and it was delicious. The filling was creamy and had a great lime taste, and the crust was just amazing. I plan on ordering the lime pie again this year.

Posted on 01/24/2018

My son received the Little Company Key Lime Pie as a Christmas/Birthday gift. The pie was packaged well, in a cooler with ice packs. No problems at all. Key Lime pie is one of our family-favorites. We have tried a lot of different ones over the years, and we know it's really hard to find a good one. So, we are pretty much "experts" on Key Lime pies. Honestly, the Key Lime pie made by the Little Pie Company is definitely one of the B-E-S-T that we have ever had!!! It had the perfect balance of sweet and tart....just delicious!!!! I would definitely buy this pie again!

West Lafayette, IN
Posted on 01/13/2018

Wonderful pie; will order more in the future. You could taste the buttery graham cracker crust. My taste buds must have had an orgasm!!! Voila!!!

West Lafayette, IN
Posted on 01/05/2018

Arrived quickly and with no hassle; pie was great, as before. I expect and receive the best from this company.

Marilee r
Barrington, IL
Posted on 10/31/2017

Excellent! Rich and creamy and very fresh. The best Key Lime Pie I have ever eaten!

Marilee r
Barrington, IL
Posted on 10/31/2017

Excellent! Rich and creamy and very fresh.

Milpitas, CA
Posted on 10/19/2017


Posted on 09/14/2017

The pie is absolutely delicious! However, delivery by UPS was quite poor. The shipping box is clearly labeled with arrows to keep box upright. The box was left on the porch on its side. Fortunately, it is a solid pie and not harmed but it could have been ruinous. The pie is outstanding!

Sudbury, MA
Posted on 06/06/2017

Delicious!! Fresh lime juice (not bottled ) taste. The perfect gift to send ahead.

West Windsor Township, NJ
Posted on 05/24/2017

Excellent key Lime Pie not too sweet not too tart,just perfect. Small than the picture but is plenty to enjoy.

Posted on 04/11/2017

Wonderful pie, smooth tart and arrived in perfect condition. Will order again

Yarmouthport, MA
Posted on 03/21/2017

The pie arrived in perfect condition. It was delicious - nice and tart, as it should be. I like that there was no whipped cream on it. I would recommend it and will order it again.

Yarmouthport, MA
Posted on 03/21/2017

The pie arrived in perfect condition. It was delicious - nice and tart, as it should be. I like that there was no whipped cream on it. I would recommend it and will order it again.

Argyle, TX
Posted on 12/25/2016

Best I've ever had. Perfect authentic flavor

Harriman, NY
Posted on 12/22/2016

It arrived on time and was DELICIOUS! This is probably the best key lime pie ever... gluten free or not

Scarsdale, NY
Posted on 12/22/2016

Absolutely, positively the finest key lime pie I've ever tasted. Bravo!!

Teaneck, NJ
Posted on 12/13/2016

Loved this pie- the taste reminded me of the key lime pies I had in Florida. Would order again. Also, the people at Foody Direct are very customer service oriented and it was a pleasure to deal with them.

Watertown, NY
Posted on 11/18/2016

Didn't really care for it.

Watertown, NY
Posted on 11/12/2016


Weirton, WV
Posted on 10/07/2016

Having lived in NYC (Manhattan) for 42 years, I've tasted many key lime pies--including some from Florida. This is absolutely the best. It is not cloyingly sweet. The flavor and texture are incomparable. I love the Little Pie Company and this pie. Delicious!

San Diego, CA
Posted on 10/06/2016

Just the right amount of a tart flavor. I loved the pie.

Rolanette s.
Falfurrias, TX
Posted on 09/30/2016

I order these all the time and pop out of the freezer for a refreshing dessert!

Silver Spring, MD
Posted on 09/21/2016

The pie I ordered was a surprise for my youngest son's birthday. He always has a key lime pie for his birthday but this year he spent his birthday hundreds of miles away from home. I was very happy with how easy the website was to navigate. The delivery date was exactly what i was told it would be. I also had to contact customer service because I was thought he lived in Silver Springs and the website said it wasn't a real address. Customer service was very nice and knew exactly what I was doing wrong so I could complete my order. My son informed me that his pie was absolutely amazing and he was quite impressed with the packaging. I will definitely use foodydirect again!

Brian j
Posted on 07/21/2016

I never been a fan of Key Lime pie but I'am now

Shipping Days
Order Cut-Off Time

All orders ship Mon thru Fri via UPS 2-Day or faster. The cut-off time for next-day shipment of orders is 6 PM (ET).

Storage & Care:

All pies from Little Pie Company should be refrigerated and enjoyed within one week of arrival, or can be frozen for up to one month. Defrost overnight in the refrigerator.<br>

Serve chilled with fresh whipped cream. Enjoy!