New York Cheesecake

Choose your Delivery Date at Check Out!

This delectable New York-style Cheesecake is a Little Pie Company best-seller that may cause them to reconsider their name. They make it with a slightly dense combination of fresh cream cheese and pure vanilla, and bake it in a sublime graham cracker crust.

Orders ship Monday through Thursday via 2-Day or Faster
Order by 6PM (ET) Tuesday for delivery by Friday

PIE OF THE MONTH CLUB ships the 2nd or 3rd week of each month

Scroll To Top
Shipping Days
Icon check Icon check Icon check Icon check Icon x

At FoodyDirect we are doing everything we can to drive down shipping costs for our customers, including offering Low Flat-Rate Shipping.

$ 9.95 Flat-Rate Shipping - If your shipping address is reachable from Little Pie Company via UPS Ground service within two days, you will be presented with the incredibly low shipping rate of $ 9.95 upon checkout.
$ 29.95 Flat-Rate Shipping - If your shipping address is beyond 2-day ground reach, you will be presented with a flat rate of just $ 29.95 for 2nd-Day Air upon checkout.

*Please note that the flat rates above will be applied per shipping box, and each shipping box contains 1 pie. You will be presented with the actual shipping rate before finalizing your purchase.

Maptemplatefinal lpc 2995

Next Day Air service and Saturday delivery may be available for an additional charge.
Service to Alaska and Hawaii is available for an additional fee. Service outside the U.S. currently not available.

Orders are shipped on Monday through Thursday, except holidays. Orders placed by 6:00 PM (ET) can be shipped the following day. For example, orders placed on Monday before 6:00 PM (ET) can be shipped as early as Tuesday. The max allowable transit time for all products is 2 days. Perishable items cannot be shipped over a weekend and cannot be delivered on Sunday or Monday.

Weather and unforeseen circumstances can delay your shipment. We strongly recommend that you schedule your order to arrive at least 1 business day before your desired usage date to allow for any delays.

Shipping Options

The following shipping options are available depending upon the delivery date selected and reflect the max allowable transit time for products from Little Pie Company:

Ground Shipping (1-2 Days) - If a customer’s shipping address is reachable via UPS Ground service within 2 days, they will be presented with a $9.95 Flat-Rate Shipping upon checkout. Orders will be delivered via UPS Ground service on or before the selected arrival date, between 9:00 AM and 8:00 PM to residences, and between 9:00 AM and 5:00 PM to businesses.

2nd-Day Air - If the shipping address is not reachable within 2 days via UPS Ground service, the customer will be presented with $29.95 Flat-Rate Shipping upon checkout. The order will be shipped via UPS 2nd-Day Air and will be delivered on or before the end of the second business day following shipment (unless upgrading to Saturday delivery). Delivery time can vary based on area, but can be as late as 8:00 p.m. to residences and 5:00 p.m. to businesses.

UPS Next Day Air Saver - Your package will be delivered by the end of the next business day after it has been shipped. Delivery time can vary based on area, but can be as late as 8:00 p.m. to residences and 5:00 p.m. to businesses. The flat-rate for Next Day Air Saver is $39.95.

UPS Next Day Air - Your package will be delivered the next morning after it has shipped (or Saturday if upgrading to Saturday delivery), by 12 noon to most addresses. The flat-rate for UPS Next Day Air is $44.95.

Saturday Delivery - Saturday delivery is available for UPS 2-Day for an additional charge of $20 per package. Deliveries are made between 9:00 AM and 8:00 PM, depending upon delivery address. Saturday delivery is not available for UPS Ground shipments.

Once your order has shipped, you will receive a ship notification email with a tracking number for each package in your order. When your order has been delivered, you will also receive a delivery notification email.

For complete shipping details we encourage you to visit our General Shipping and Packaging Information page.

Packaging & Delivery

All pies from Little Pie Company are shipped frozen in extra thick recyclable foam containers with sufficient coolant to assure it arrives in excellent condition within the max allowable transit time of 2 days.

All orders are shipped signature release. This means UPS will leave the package at the doorstep, front desk or gate associated with the shipping address without requiring a signature upon delivery. It is the customer's responsibility to ensure that the contents of the package are stored in a freezer or refrigerator promptly after delivery. FoodyDirect cannot be responsible for orders with incomplete or invalid addresses, or that are sent to recipients who are not available to store the contents of the order on the day of arrival. UPS cannot deliver to a P.O. box.

Storage & Care

All pies should be refrigerated and enjoyed within one week of arrival, or can be frozen for up to one month.

Order Cut-Off Time:

All orders ship Mon thru Fri via UPS 2-Day or faster. The cut-off time for same-day shipment of orders is Noon (ET).

Storage & Care:

NY Cheesecakes from Little Pie Company should be refrigerated and enjoyed within 6 days of arrival, or can be frozen for up to one month if well-wrapped. Defrost overnight in the refrigerator.

Serve chilled with fresh fruit or fruit glazes if you so desire. Enjoy!

8 reviews

Rev olivia
Crisfield, MD
Posted on 03/11/2018

delicious! flavor was wonderful, composition was not too heavy. Will order again!

Leesburg, IN
Posted on 03/03/2018

This cheesecake was so, so delicious. It was wrapped very well and it got here whole and not broken! I wish I could order more, but I'm going to have to save up money!! My son has loved cheesecake his whole life and he said it was the best he's ever had!!

Philadelphia, PA
Posted on 01/31/2018

Creamy and just delicious. Would highly recommend for the cheesecake lover in your life.

Carlisle, PA
Posted on 03/06/2017

This is not a heavy cheesecake it is light but with the right amount of density - just awesome

Anthony, FL
Posted on 03/03/2017

Perfection! My husband is very particular about his cheesecake and he LOVED this! I am not normally a cheesecake person, but I will say, FAB!

Leatrice gilbert
Monticello, NY
Posted on 02/03/2017

DELICIOUS PIE well packed no complaints only kudos.

Cherry Hill, NJ
Posted on 02/02/2017

Fast delivery service. Excellent cheesecake. Can't ask for anything more. Jack

Posted on 08/06/2016

The NY Cheesecake from the Little Pie Company is delicious and melts in our mouth. I am very happy with my order!