Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie

Choose your Delivery Date at Check Out!

BLUE RIBBON WINNER! - Everyday with Rachael Ray
BEST APPLE PIE IN NEW YORK! - The Daily News - Best of New York

Little Pie Company’s signature pie and bestseller is made with thinly sliced Granny Smith Apples and fresh sour cream. Incredibly rich and not overly sweet, it’s topped with a scrumptious brown sugar, cinnamon and walnut streusel for a pie experience you’ll never forget.

Orders ship Monday through Thursday via 2-Day or Faster
Ruffino Prosecco Pie ships via overnight only

Scroll To Top

29 reviews
5
26
4
3
3
2
1

R
Posted on 10/31/2018

When i first moved to New York, I lived on the 46th floor of Manhattan Plaza - the Little Pie Company was an extraordinary treat with the sour cream apple walnut pie, the crown jewel. There was a hand-written note from Angela Lansbury honoring the Little Pie Company in character from Sweeney Todd “to the best pie makers in New York from the worst pie maker in London”. My very first Thanksgiving away from home before I ever learned to make a pie was buying their pies. Every year thereafter, I either carried a pie home on a plane or had my mom bring one. After I lost my mom, I have never been so grateful for a delivery service in all my life that we’re able to order one online. It’s been 25 years since that first pie and still as delicious. The pie itself is a curious. The brown-sugar walnut topping counterbalances perfectly the sour-cream tart apple-filling and crumbly crust. It’s an ideal balance of flavour and texture. Trt the Carrot Cake and pecan snail, too!

Miranda
Silver Spring, MD
Posted on 09/29/2018

I have been longing for an apple pie! This pie popped up in several articles I read, so I had to try it. The thinly sliced apples and the sour cream element make this pie unique. However , it’s the topping that make it fabulous. It perfectly balances the apples and sour cream to make the pie sweet, but not too sweet. You will find yourself scraping the plate with your fork, so you get all of the little bits and bites that were left behind. A must try if you love apple pie. (Or even if you’re lukewarm about apple pie. This pie will change your mind...)

Bob
Smithville, OH
Posted on 07/27/2018

this apple pie was to die for, if someone said this is your last meal, I would be sure this apple pie would be on it.

Julie
Posted on 02/09/2018

the pie was excellent and packed really well!

Maryann
Staten Island, NY
Posted on 01/01/2018

The pie was absolutely delicious and I was happy with my purchase. The crumble on top and walnuts was nice and crunchy and the apples were thinly sliced, plentiful and a little tart, love green apples! Would definitely recommend this pie to others! A real winner!

Mary
Weirton, WV
Posted on 12/30/2017

Best apple pie ever! From the topping to the crust, this pie is scrumptious. One of my favorite pies from the Little Pie Company.

Angel
Lyman, SC
Posted on 12/29/2017

Best pie in the world delivered right to my door! I used to live down the block from the Little Pu Company in NYC and now I can enjoy the pies I miss so much, in South Carolina.!

Jennifer
Birmingham, MI
Posted on 12/28/2017

In a fluke chance I tasted the very last piece AFTER a thanksgiving at someone else home...they didn't know where it came from and since it was the best damn pie I'd ever had, I hunted the info down from the guest that had brought it. Went forward and sent 6 pies to various people (two to myself!) and have heard from all that it was also 'the best damn pie they'd ever had' - seriously - we have pie makers in our family and I consider them all retired as of this discovery! Can't wait to order more-

Verity
fresh meadows, NY
Posted on 11/30/2017

I was never a pie eater until this. So Good! Does not disappoint, everyone loves it when I bring it

Mary
Weirton, WV
Posted on 11/30/2017

While I love all of the pies, this is my favorite. I order it for myself, as well as for other friends and family members. It's just scrumptious.

Greg b
Carmel, CA
Posted on 11/30/2017

This is our favorite pie. It got here before Thanksgiving and was a real hit. Been buying it for the last 5 years and is always consistent.

Donna
Haverhill, MA
Posted on 11/29/2017

The sour cream apple walnut pie was delicious. Delivery arrived on the day I requested. I'll definitely order from this company again.

Cathy
Statesboro, GA
Posted on 11/27/2017

This pie was a complete surprise to me as it was a gift from a coworker! It was DELICIOUS!! We have about 10 people working here, so we all shared it. I liked it so well that I plan to order from all of you for Christmas! What a treat.... Regards, Cathy S.

Bea j
Bloomington, IN
Posted on 09/24/2017

This pie is delicious. Not a huge fan of fruit pies, but the sour cream and walnuts put this over the top!!! Will be ordering again.

Danielle
Fredericksburg, VA
Posted on 06/15/2017

My dad barely sends one text with two words in it, and he's sent me three texts detailing how delicious this pie is! I'm so happy:) My friend Lisa recommended this particular pie from your company and so glad I listened to her. Thanks for making father's day special for my dad!!! :)

Bryan a
Ocala, FL
Posted on 01/26/2017

I had ordered and send this pie as a gift. They were raved about it.

Kathleen
Westlake Village, CA
Posted on 01/08/2017

Haven't had this pie since we moved to the west coast 12 years ago. It's still delicious! A wonderful way to welcome the New Year!!

Jim b
Smithfield, NC
Posted on 01/03/2017

Great pie and arrived on schedule!

Tara
Clay, NY
Posted on 12/07/2016

Outstanding apple pie. I'm an apple pie snob as it is my favorite all-time dessert. This pie beats the majority of hand-crafted pies. The texture and taste were well above par! I would order again for a special occasion.

Brender
Snellville, GA
Posted on 12/03/2016

It hasn't been eaten yet. Arrived as we were leaving Atlanta BUT I do commend the speedy email & refund & the pie was still delivered! I gave a Very Good because I LOVED my 1st one I received as a birthday gift in Aug. Lord help I ate the whole (small) one by myself. I will order again Ms. Brender, Tulsa, OK

Gloria
Wheaton, IL
Posted on 12/03/2016

Sour cream apple pie made my Thanksgiving day feel like a day at the beach and I live in the Midwest and believe me I was not at the beach. It's a very good pie. G K

Elsy
Loxahatchee, FL
Posted on 12/03/2016

Great pie! I Do not regret ordering in blind faith.

Anne
Aldie, VA
Posted on 12/02/2016

This is the second time ordering this pie for our family thanksgiving dinner. It's one of the best apple pies I've ever had. I've also given this as a gift.

Tara
Clay, NY
Posted on 11/30/2016

I'm an apple pie snob - if it doesn't come out of your oven, then it can't possibly be good. Boy, did this place prove me wrong!! Amazing pie - perfect balance of sweet and tart with nice consistency. Awesome stand-in for our belated Thanksgiving feast!

Donna
Tampa, FL
Posted on 11/28/2016

Love this pie! Recently moved from NYC and needed a bit of home.

Elizabeth
Menifee, CA
Posted on 11/21/2016

The BEST pie I have ever had!!

Scott
Saint Marks, FL
Posted on 09/16/2016

Pie arrived timely, in perfect condition. Pie was good, but not quite as good as I had hoped. Others should know I had very high expectations. My grandmother used to make a Sour Cream Dutch Apple Pie with Walnuts and since her passing I've been trying to find one as good. Sadly this pie is not, but that doesn't mean others won't find Little Pie Company's effort magnificent. 3.5 stars.

Michael d
Chevy chase, MD
Posted on 09/09/2016

This pie is legendary. The first time I had this pie was back in the mid to late 80s. My besties in NYC lived on 43rd street across from the bakery and we bought this pie to share on Thanksgiving when none of us had any money to buy anything. It was the most delicious thing I had ever eaten. Since then I have tried to recreate this pie 100 times to no avail. Martha Stewart has tried to recreate it......no one can. This is the most amazing pie I have ever eaten. It reminds me of longtime friends, the Macy's Thanksgiving Day Parade and days when anything west 8th Avenue was dangerous. I can now afford to buy any pie I want..... I buy this pie and have it sent to my most dearest friends during the holidays. it is like sending love in the mail.

Marc
Cumming, GA
Posted on 07/12/2016

My Daughter just got married on this past 4th of July. Since her and her husband aren't really "cake" people we had these pies shipped for their wedding. They were a big hit! Everyone wanted to know where we got them and how much they loved them. Although a little pricey to buy and ship 15 pies, it was well worth it. Best pies ever!

Shipping Days
MON TUE WED THU FRI
Order Cut-Off Time

All orders ship Mon thru Fri via UPS 2-Day or faster. The cut-off time for next-day shipment of orders is 6 PM (ET).

Storage & Care:

All pies from Little Pie Company should be refrigerated and enjoyed within one week of arrival, or can be frozen for up to one month. Defrost overnight in the refrigerator.<br>

Optional Heating Instructions - Remove from the refrigerator 1-2 hours before heating. Preheat your oven to 325°F and heat for 20 minutes. Let topping cool before serving. Enjoy!