Caramel and Cream Smith Island Cake

Choose your Delivery Date at Check Out!

Created exclusively for Smith Island Baking Co. by Chef de Cuisine, the Bartlett Pear Inn's Jordan Lloyd, this take on a Southern classic is guaranteed to amaze. Featuring layers of moist yellow cake, housemade caramel, a light, fluffy caramel buttercream, and topped with caramel drizzle.

Shipped frozen with dry ice in a recyclable cake box.

Scroll To Top

2 reviews

West Hempstead, NY
Posted on 02/01/2018

I must say this cake was very good will order again everyone loved it

Arlington, VA
Posted on 06/15/2016

Since this cake was a gift, my review is necessarily second hand. In thanking me on behalf of her family, the recipient told me that everyone enjoyed it immensely. I've ordered a Smith Island cake previously and enjoyed it myself, so I decided to try using Smith Island again to send a birthday-type cake. Originally, I had planned to order the all-chocolate version, but switched to this one when I noted that it was on sale. Not only was it well worth the price, but the shipping and handling was done flawlessly.

Shipping Days
Order Cut-Off Time:

All orders ship Mon through Thurs via 2-Day or faster. Orders placed by 6:00AM (ET) can ship as early as that day.

Storage & Care:

All cakes should be kept refrigerated in an air-tight container, such as a cake dome. In these conditions, cakes maintain freshness for 5 - 7 days. All Smith Island cakes freeze wonderfully. If you have left over cake, wrap it well and freeze it.