Cooked Coconut Smith Island Cake

Choose your Delivery Date at Check Out!

One taste of the Cooked Coconut Smith Island Cake and you’ll know why this amazingly delicious cake is one of SIBC’s bestsellers. Order it and you’ll savor layers upon layers of impossibly moist yellow cake and rich coconut icing topped with gorgeous coconut shavings.

Standing 3.5 inches tall and 9 inches in diameter, this glorious cake yields 14 to 16 slices. Like all SIBC cakes, it’s shipped frozen with dry ice in a recyclable cake box.

Scroll To Top

6 reviews

Rodanthe, NC
Posted on 12/14/2017

My first order through your company and it was this coconut cake being sent to my Brother on the Outer Banks. Just got a message that it had arrived and was wonderful!! Thank you for helping me make their Christmas a little sweeter.

Panama City, FL
Posted on 09/22/2016

The toasted coconut cake was perfect. Packaged very well...still frozen when arrived. Cake was totally delicious! Will definitely be ordering again very soon!

Mobile, AL
Posted on 08/24/2016

OMG..... this is by far the best coconut cake that my family and I have ever eaten. Have purchased several times and the results are always the same, FABLOUS !!!! Even those that only want a small piece at first come, back for more. This is truly my new indulgence.

John d messersmith
Edisto Island, SC
Posted on 07/29/2016

I sent this coconut cake to my Mom in South Carolina. She called me the next day and raved about it! She wants me to send another as soon as I can. She asked me to make sure I sent in a review as this is one of the best coconut cakes she has ever had! That makes me very happy! I'm ordering one for me!

Posted on 07/28/2016

The cake arrived well-wrapped, frozen, and in perfect condition. It took several hours to thaw, due to the density of the layers, but tasted fresh and delicious. This was purchased as a birthday cake for my 95 yr-old mother-in-law, who thoroughly enjoyed it as well! We were pleased and would order again for a special occasion.

Hoboken, NJ
Posted on 06/17/2016

An awesome cake! The cake is moist and delicious, the frosting is rich and decadent, just what a great cake should be! We've been serving this cake (and their chocolate cake) for large holiday gatherings - everyone raves about it, and it feeds a lot of people! We've also sent this cake as a gift to our parents who live in a seniors community and it's been a huge hit there as well!

Shipping Days
Order Cut-Off Time:

All orders ship Mon through Thurs via 2-Day or faster. Orders placed by 6:00AM (ET) can ship as early as that day.

Storage & Care:

Chocolate fudge frosted cakes keep best stored at room temperature. Our other cakes should be refrigerated. All cakes should be kept in an air-tight container, such as a cake dome. In these conditions, cakes maintain freshness for 5 - 7 days. All Smith Island cakes freeze wonderfully. If you have left over cake, wrap it well and freeze it.