Original Chocolate Smith Island Cake

Choose your Delivery Date at Check Out!

This heritage cake is Smith Island Baking Company’s most popular offering as well as Maryland's official State Dessert. Made from scratch and comprised of layers of impossibly moist yellow cake and heavenly fudge icing, it stands 3.5 inches tall and 9 inches in diameter, yielding 14 to 16 slices. Like all SIBC cakes, it it’s shipped frozen with dry ice in a recyclable cake box.

Scroll To Top

6 reviews

Posted on 10/12/2018

The cake arrived in perfect condition. It was delicious! Everyone loved it! I will definitely order it again.

Malden, MA
Posted on 10/11/2018

I love this company the smith island baking co. their cakes are so good, the first time I ever heard about them was when they were on QVC, many years ago, I got this cake the original then, also on their website with the very high shipping, did that once, now Foody Direct, you have them cakes with reasonable shipping thank you, you couldn't ask for a better tasting cake with all the layers plus the chocolate frosting within not overly sweet either, just pure bliss. go with FOODY DIRECT you won't be sorry you did.

Glen Arm, MD
Posted on 07/09/2018

Always was curious about this cake, looks so good - and it is. Saved 1/2 of it for my own birthday coming up in a month.

Toledo, OH
Posted on 11/20/2016

This cake is so good!!! I thought it was not enough chocolate on the cake but it is just right!! Wow I'm impressed with the taste of this cake I ordered it for Thanksgiving and I cut me a slice, I'm glad I did. I tried to order another one right away but they sold out! Please try this Original Chocolate Smith Cake you won't be sorry.

Panama City, FL
Posted on 09/22/2016

I was apprehensive to order the chocolate cake thinking it would be really sweet....It was absolutely delicious! It was not too sweet nor was there too much icing. It was wonderful & I will be ordering again.

Hoboken, NJ
Posted on 06/17/2016

An awesome cake! The cake is moist and delicious, the frosting is rich and decadent, just what a great cake should be! We've been serving this cake (and their coconut cake) for large holiday gatherings for several years - everyone always raves about it, and it feeds a lot of people! We've also sent as a gift to our parents who live in a seniors community and it's been a huge hit there!

Shipping Days
Order Cut-Off Time:

All orders ship Mon through Thurs via 2-Day or faster. Orders placed by 6:00AM (ET) can ship as early as that day.

Storage & Care:

Chocolate fudge frosted cakes keep best stored at room temperature. Our other cakes should be refrigerated. All cakes should be kept in an air-tight container, such as a cake dome. In these conditions, cakes maintain freshness for 5 - 7 days. All Smith Island cakes freeze wonderfully. If you have left over cake, wrap it well and freeze it.