Fresh Challah Custom Two-Pack

Choose your Delivery Date at Check Out!

Nut Free, kosher-certified, and dairy-free, the Challah Fairy’s light and fluffy handmade loaves come in classic flavors such as plain or sesame, and sweeter contemporary flavors, like chocolate chip and cinnamon with a house-made vanilla crumb topping. Enjoy with a traditional Friday night Shabbat dinner, as a soft sandwich bread, or as an incredible French toast breakfast.

Select two delicious loaves from the following flavors:

  • Plain
  • Sesame
  • Everything
  • Vanilla Crumb
  • Cinnamon Crumb
  • Chocolate Chip Crumb
  • Raisin
  • Cinnamon Raisin
  • Whole Wheat
  • Vegan (fat-free, oil-free, egg-free and sugar-free)

Ships Monday through Thursday via 2-Day or faster
Order by Wednesday at 10 AM (ET) for delivery by Friday

Scroll To Top

12 reviews

Franklin Square, NY
Posted on 03/21/2018

Love love love this Challah bread! Already turned my co-workers into Challah Fairy fans - they in turn are ordering. Makes the best french toast you will ever taste!

Posted on 03/08/2018

Disappointed in the flavor because everything was bland.

Rev olivia
Crisfield, MD
Posted on 11/09/2017

as always, just wonderful. Melts in your mouth!

Jersey City, NJ
Posted on 10/06/2017

So fresh so tasty and so easy to get to your house before Shabbat. Chocolate Chip Crumble Challah......who knew? But am i glad i found this....DELICIOUS.

Jersey City, NJ
Posted on 08/23/2017

YUM - absolutely delicious loved the plain Challah and the Chocolate Chip absolutely incredible. WOW - Challot came well packaged and quick! Thank you and looking forward to my delivery tomorrow!

Denton, TX
Posted on 02/11/2017

Fantastic!!!! I have never ate challah bread so I ordered the regular and raisin my goodness it was so good. Will be order it again. Great price as well. Bread was so fresh and even when I put in toaster it was so nice and soft on the inside. Will b ordering again!!

Denton, TX
Posted on 02/06/2017

They were soooo good! great taste great price!!! will order again! I recommend it.

Voorhees Township, NJ
Posted on 12/24/2016

DELICIOUS, best Challah ever! Fast service, great customer service at Foody Direct

Voorhees Township, NJ
Posted on 12/15/2016

Delicious, sweet and tasty!!!

superior, CO
Posted on 10/08/2016

excellent product

Virginia Beach, VA
Posted on 10/08/2016

Great taste and perfect for the High Holidays!

Arlington, VA
Posted on 10/06/2016

Underwhelming and far, far, far too small.

Storage & Care:

Enjoy your challahs within two days of arrival, or freeze for up to 4 to 6 weeks. Defrost at room temperature for 3-4 hours.


Slice challah to desired thickness, soak briefly in a mix of equal parts eggs & milk. Place in hot buttered pan until brown on both sides. Sprinkle with powdered sugar and dredge in maple syrup. Enjoy!

Allergy Alert:

The Challah Fairy is a NUT-FREE bakery

Dietary Restrictions:

The Challah Fairy is KOSHER-certified (under the supervision of Rabbi Zushe Blech) <br> All Challahs are Dairy-Free